In alt.home.repair, on Sat, 29 Apr 2023 23:19:38 -0000 (UTC), Maxmillian
Post by MaxmillianIn your experience, what percentage of your flat tires have to have the
tire replaced versus just having the flat repaired?
I realize everything is up to chance, but in the last couple of years, my
household has had three flat tires, all due to nails or screws (there is
always some construction going on nearby) where I took the tires to
GoodYear and all three had to be replaced.
One, as I recall, was too close to the shoulder, the other had been driven
on (they said) when they removed the carcass, and just yesterday, the third
they said was worn to a wear bar (as it had uneven wear) but it seemed to
me to be barely above the wear bar at the one wear bar he pointed to as
most of the tread was about two or three mm above the wear bars so he
picked the lowest one at about a millimeter or less above the wear bar).
After waiting two hours in the waiting room, the guy came back and said he
can't repair a dangerous tire, so again, for the third time, I had to buy a
new tire, where it took another hour for them to have the car ready for me.
Given I had to remove the tire anyway to put on the spare, the whole ordeal
took about five hours or so in elapsed time just to fix a basic flat.
Could I have more easily just repaired the tire at home?
Years ago I used to get quite a few flats. Maybe because I lived in a
city with glass and nails on the street (although not every flat was in
the city.)
I fixed quite a few flats myself, first with plugs and later with
"strings" They sell them at any auto parts store. They also selll
them with a tool to insert the string, but when I'm depressed, I cheer
myself up by buying a new tool, so I bought a better insert tool. That
seems to be the best way to stop havign flats, spend $3 on the better
tool.
On one and only one occasions in the last 50 years, I've been able to
inflate a tire with Fix-a-Flat and drive on it without losing much
pressure at least until I got home -- without removign whatever made the
leak. But other times, the air went out almost as fast as it went in.
Nonetheless, I still carry it. One can is not enough because if you
need it and use it, you have no more for the next flat. Two cans is not
enough, because if you use one can, you only have one can left and I
just determined that one can is not enough. So I usually have 3 cans.
That also prevents having flats in the first place.
Now I carry an ectric tire pump but when I didn't, afte4r I patched it
myself, one can of Fix-a-Flat would put in enough air to drive to
somewhere there was an air pump.
Post by MaxmillianI realize everything is up to chance but has it been your experience that
almost all the tires you want to repair, they say can't be repaired?
Once someoen even repaired a hole in a sidewall for me. I don't think
they are lying when they say y ou can't do this, but somehow he did.
At a shop I expect them to take the tire off the rim and patch it on the
inside, and he did that to a sidewall. AIUI, removing the tire and using
a patch is better, but it's so much extra work and couldn't be much
better since strings work fine except in sidewalls.
But I saw shops where all they do is put in strings, which btw doesn't
require taking off the tire, and if they're going to just do that, I
can do that as well as they can. Once the tire is off the car and the
leak is found, inserting a string takes 5 minutes or less.
In one case, I removed the nail and patched the tire without even taking
the tire off the car.
Post by MaxmillianThen there's the added cost of sales tax of around ten dollars, mounting
and balancing at around fifteen dollars, and the tire valve of five dollars
and the disposal fee of about another five dollars. It all adds up.
I'm wondering if it's worth it to buy a "tire press" or whatever it takes
to change a tire (I have a small portable compressor already) at home.
Anyone repair your own tires at home when you get a flat?
Is it worth the money if you can save a few tires?
I thought so, not just the cost of the tire but the time and effort like
you say.
I doubt you will find a place like Baltimore has, but ... Back in 1970,
when someone borrowed my car and wrecked it, he bent the frame and one
tire kept wearing out sooner than it should, so I started buying used
tires for it. Maybe logically that reason is not a good one. And if
you drive 20,000 miles a year maybe it's not worth it
But I continued it and in Baltimore there is one place that always has
the size I need, and it takes under 10 minutes start to finish to buy a
tire or two. (I've never bought mroe than 2 at one time.)
They have space for two cars inside the shop but if they run out of
space, guys some out to the sidewalk and the street. They know why
people are there, so they don't need to waste more than a few seconds
talking. If you need two, two guys jack up two corners, they take off
the wheels and give them to someone else who takes off the tires, Then
they go in the back to find the tires, give them to that rim guy who
mounts the new tires and igves them to another guy who bubble tests
them, then to another one who balances them, dynamically, who gives them
back to the two guys (or maybe two other guys) who put the tires back
on. While they do all that, I'm going into the office to pay, a middle
aged woman.
All this takes under 10 minutes, once only 5, but once it took 13
minutes counting waiting. It's a 20 minute drive from here but I enjoy
the drive.
They work on up to 6 cars at once, 12 or 14 guys at busy times. They've
all been nice guys. All they sell are used tires. Well it says they
sell new tires too, but they assume I'm there for used tires. If they
ever didn't have my size, I guess they'd sell me new. it's been 5
years since I bought a tire, but I think prices were 15 to 50 depending
on how much tread is left, and the size of the tire. My tires are not
especially big and I don't think they've ever asked for more than 35.
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-d&q=dana%27s+tires I'm
surprised it's only 4.4 stars on 373 reviews. A good friend found them
separately from me and never bought tires anywhere else
Many used tires look pretty good, except maybe the 10 dollar tires
(which I've never looked at) with more than half the tread left, mmany
(most?) from accidents where the car is totalled and the tires might be
like new.
It used to be some new-car buyers would have the original tires replaced
with better ones and the ones removed were sold as used, but I don't
know if that still happens. CAn't imagine it's many.
They don't use plugs anymore aiui. Plugs require rubber cement be
applied. Strings dont, plus I think they go better in small holes.
I only use strings. This kit has more than you need, but I have not yet
found a smaller kit.
https://www.amazon.com/Vehiclex-Compact-Repair-Supplies-Punctures/dp/B091CLPZJ7/ref=sr_1_3_sspa
You don't need the patch, or the razor and you probably have a tire
gauge. It makes sense to have a tire valve tool and a spare valve but
I've never needed one.
This is more like it
https://www.amazon.com/T-Handle-String-Compact-Professional-Repair/dp/B093BWHD5P/ref=sr_1_19_sspa
20 strings, a lifetime supply. I don't konw about those angled tools,
but maybe they're better.